Why do people think Brooke should not have gone home??

ok, im a big fan of America's Next Top Model. I know some think it superficial but it's entertainment!!! im so sick of people complaining about Brooke being eliminated last night, and they keep hating on Tyra, like shes the devil for letting such a nice 18 year old go. thats not what the competition is about and i think people keep forgetting what the fashion/model industry really is! its not nice, AT ALL...so why do you expect Tyra to cut slack? i think Brooke was just a cute, sweet girl. i didnt see a "top model" at all. the ones you all hate the most, like Anchal and Jaeda...for having a lack of confidence..they really have the looks and height it takes to sell in this industry. i hope Anchal steps it up and wins.the twins are boring and have really bad posture/hunchbacks. also, Eugena is pretty but pimply..BUT with clear skin she has top model looks. so does Jaeda,but ppl say she looks manly..that works in photos %26amp; looks more edgy. caridee is the typical blonde, its boring. period.

Why do people think Brooke should not have gone home??
The truth is that this season is highly debated. Brooke, yes she is a young , pretty girl yet she was sent home. Face it, someone has to go every week. I know it hurts to see your faves go : hush...I am black and I do not think that Jada and Eugena are been kept there because of their color. They show potential but I am just tired of hearing Jada whine about her hair.





Another big night for Melrose, she is not that popular but might just end up winning. And what the hell has gotten to Tyra's head, she seems unnecessarily harsh at times...- chill out girl
Reply:You know, I think they set up some of the girls to go home. You see them taking photos and then they choose one to represent them. How do you know that they are actually choosing the best? I liked brooke, but I really don't care. I would rather that Melrose goes. She's really irritating. I guess that's why she isn't leaving.
Reply:Yes, Brooke was cute and sweet in person, but she was also able to bring a certain depth and soul to her photos that empty-eyed Eugenia and pathetic "Boo-hoo-I-have-short-hair" Jaeda never could, yet they are still around and Brooke is gone. A model needs to be able to take good PHOTOS. Sure, Eugenia and Jaeda are gorgeous, but it takes more than that to make it as a model, as Tyra herself likes to say rather often. If you can't deliver on film, you should go. Brooke delivered. AJ delivered (she was too cool for the cheesy couple photo shot. You could tell she thought it was stupid). Caridee (I disagree with you - she brings a uniqueness and style to her photos that make her more than a typical blonde), Melrose, the twins, and even Anchal deliver, but Eugenia and Jaeda don't, yet they are still on the show. That's what bummed me out. Brooke had far more promise than Jaeda and Eugenia combined. And Anchal? Gorgeous, yes, but completely devoid of confidence. A shame too because she could totally run off with this thing.
Reply:i didn't feel like she had the worst pictures this week. i'd give that to jaeda or eugena. part of working in the industry is being able to be approachable. not saying the person has to be super nice just approachable, and humble. melrose to me has the worst attitude of the girls remaining.





i love tyra, but i do think this season she is a little more into herself. i understand it is a show and they want good tv. i'm just surprised by the way this season has gone so far.





i love anchal but she needs to be confident!